| 2018 |
Michael Tempel |
Cashtown Pirates |
| 2017 |
Austin Kibler (co-winner) |
Hanover Raiders |
| |
Zach Ketterman (co-winner) |
Cashtown Pirates |
| 2016 |
Austin Roth |
New Oxford Twins |
| 2015 |
Beau Deatrick |
Hanover Raiders |
| 2014 |
Justin Keith |
Littlestown Dodgers |
| 2013 |
Nathan Topper (co-winner) |
Hanover Raiders |
| |
Brett Smith (co-winner) |
Brushtown Bulldogs |
| 2012 |
Zach Michael |
Cashtown Pirates |
| 2011 |
Charlie Werner |
New Oxford Twins |
| 2010 |
Tyler Mentzer |
Brushtown Bulldogs |
| 2009 |
Paul Bingham |
Littlestown Dodgers |
| 2008 |
Zack Keffer (co-winner) |
Hanover Raiders |
| |
Zack Mentzer (co-winner) |
Brushtown Bulldogs |
| 2007 |
Paul Bingham |
Littlestown Dodgers |
| 2006 |
Andy Bucher |
Littlestown Dodgers |
| 2005 |
Darren Groft |
Brushtown Bulldogs |
| 2004 |
Kyle Knouse |
Biglerville Black Sox |
| 2003 |
Mike Robinson |
Hanover Raiders |
| 2002 |
Jesse Murren |
New Oxford Twins |
| 2001 |
Jason Boyd |
Littlestown Dodgers |
| 2000 |
Andy McCormick |
New Oxford Twins |
| 1999 |
Vince Stonesifer |
Taneytown Cardinals |
| 1998 |
Chris May (co-winner) |
Biglerville Black Sox |
| |
Jason Brezler (co-winner) |
Carroll County Rangers |
| 1997 |
Todd Myers |
Gettysburg Generals |
| 1996 |
Dan Rhodes |
Hanover Raiders |
| 1995 |
Travis Byers |
Biglerville Black Sox |
| 1994 |
Steve Chroniger (co-winner) |
Hanover Raiders |
| |
Chris Skowronski (co-winner) |
Cashtown Pirates |
| 1993 |
Les Davis |
Thurmont Rangers |
| 1992 |
Jim Beard |
New Oxford Twins |
| 1991 |
Scott Thomson |
Taneytown Cardinals |
| 1990 |
Kevin Peart |
Littlestown Dodgers |